Skip to main content

Walk with pride and hope. No FIR Against Physicians, Supreme Court


In an important decision Hon'ble Supreme Court of India said, that if the advise of a lawyer goes wrong in some way, or a good outcome doesn't come as a result of a treatment by a doctor, even than no case under section 420 IPC (Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property) or 109 IPC (Punishment of abetment if the act abetted is committed in consequence and where no express provision is made for its punishment) or something like that can be registered against lawyer or doctor unless there are strong evidence that establish relation of advocate with criminals involved in the case.
Court also said that in professions like lawyers and doctors, the professionals cannot guarantee for the success of the case. Courts said that the advocate cannot provide guarantee to his/her client that he would definitely win the case and nor doctor can tell his patient that is operations are always successful. And though this professions doctor and lawyer can only say that they are experienced in their work and they would do their best efforts so that they are successful. SC opined that there is a world of difference between giving of improper legal advice and wrong legal advice”.
The case being heard is that CBI has asked for advise of a lawyer on title deed in a matter of loan. The lawyer have given a clean chit to that deed at that time, but after that the scandal of millions took place on the same deed. CBI registered a criminal case against the lawyer under section 420 and others that was dismissed by High Court. After this, CBI went to Supreme Court in appeal against the order, which the Hon'ble Supreme Court also dismissed. Justice bench said while giving decision that a case cannot be registered against a lawyer just because his advice was not right. The wrong advice of the lawyer can be considered negligence or professional misconduct, that too only when there is strong evidence.
So a Doctor can treat a patient with common standard justifiable knowledge of medicine available in his/her access of diagnosis and treatment need not to follow the best available standard or specialist or super specialist workup but have to be remain vigilant for any untoward side effect or complication requiring early detection or referral But  no recovery /cure is yardstick of competency, any failure cant be considered as negligence or professional misconduct and thus no FIR for criminal case or consumer court can be initiated against a doctor.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Low cost Bariatric Surgery in India for obese people with amazing cost saving for International Patients

Obesity now days being worlds most affecting health disorder and giving rise to a lot of various health hazards is the biggest threat to population through out the world. Our Low cost Bariatric surgery is the best proven method that results in a durable weight loss. Diets and other medical plans for weight loss have been shown to have very poor long term results and all with inability to maintain the weight loss. Long term weight loss without Bariatric surgery is only achieved by 5-10% of obese women, man and children. The people getting the Bariatric surgery throughout the world is the highest in western country itself it is estimated that around every year more than 200,000 bariatric surgeries are being performed in US itself still a lot of people needing the surgery  are unable to the get the surgery because of various factors such as the high end cost of the surgery, the surgery not being covered by the insurance or sometimes not getting the appointments. These have been...
23 comments
Read more

Ideal medical tourism destination

Goa with it combination of super specialty hospitals and luxurious hotels, has been touted as an ideal medical tourism destination where ailing foreigners can combine a relaxing holiday with cheap but effective medical treatment. But the state is seeing a new trend: hitching onto the medico-leisure bandwagon are dentists who are offering their services at a fraction of the price their foreign clients would expect to pay at home.  Dr. Ambert Pimenta, for example catches the attention of prospective clients with a simple promise: get your dental treatment in Goa and holiday for free. His website ( www.goadentist.com ) says, "Yes as I promised, here is how you can make your holiday to Goa absolutely FREE ! Consider how much you pay in Europe or America ...are the long lines and frustrating long waits at an NHS dentist wearing you down ? Compare our pricing with that of any NHS service or private practice for that matter, we will leave the competition behind. The subsequent arithmetic...
3 comments
Read more

Orthopedic treatment in India

Orthopedics is one of the common procedures for which international patient often travel to India, orthopedic surgery and orthopedic treatment in India is available at state-of-the art medical centers. With fully-equipped operation theatres, expert orthopedic surgeons and the back-up support of labs and blood banks, Orthopedic hospitals in India provide comprehensive treatment for ortho related disorders.   Major surgeries performed are   Joint Replacement Hip Resurfacing Hip replacement Knee surgery Knee Arthroplasty Hand Reconstruction Arthroscopic surgery Trauma and Fracture surgery
1 comment
Read more